Sticks, Stones, and Ideology: The Discourse of Reform in Teacher Education
- 1 November 2001
- journal article
- Published by American Educational Research Association (AERA) in Educational Researcher
- Vol. 30 (8), 3-15
- https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x030008003
Abstract
Many highly politicized debates about reforming teacher education are embedded within two larger national agendas: the agenda to professionalize teaching and teacher education, which is linked to the K–12 standards movement, and the movement to deregulate teacher preparation, which aims to dismantle teacher education institutions and break up the monopoly of the profession. In this article, the authors analyze how these two agendas are publicly constructed, critiqued, and debated, drawing on public documents from each side and using the language and arguments of the advocates themselves. The authors argue that, despite very different agendas, the discourse of both deregulation and professionalization revolves rhetorically around the establishment of three interrelated warrants, which legitimize certain policies and undermine others. Taken together, what Cochran-Smith and Fries label “the evidentiary warrant,” “the political warrant,” and “the accountability warrant,” are intended by advocates of competing agendas to add up to “common sense” about how to improve the quality of the nation’s teachers. The authors conclude that in order to understand the politics of teacher education and the complexities of competing reform agendas, their underlying ideals, ideologies, and values must be debated along with and in relation to “the evidence” about teacher quality.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- The outcomes question in teacher educationTeaching and Teacher Education, 2001
- Markets, Standards, Teaching, and Teacher EducationJournal of Teacher Education, 2001
- CAN CRITICAL PEDAGOGIES INTERRRUPT RIGHTIST POLICIES?Educational Theory, 2000
- Reforming Teacher Preparation and Licensing: What is the Evidence?Teachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education, 2000
- Reforming Teacher Preparation and Licensing: Debating the EvidenceTeachers College Record: the Voice of Scholarship in Education, 2000
- The Politics of Teacher Education Reform: Strategic Philanthropy and Public Policy MakingEducational Policy, 2000
- Finding the Culprit: Federal Policy and Teacher EducationEducational Policy, 2000
- Teaching for America's Future: National Commissions and Vested Interests in an Almost ProfessionEducational Policy, 2000
- The Role of Accreditation Reform in Teacher EducationEducational Policy, 2000
- Public Goods, Private Goods: The American Struggle Over Educational GoalsAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1997