UltraCision harmonic scalpel versus clamp‐and‐tie total thyroidectomy: A clinical trial

Abstract

Background Hemostasis is important in thyroid surgery to avoid complications. Our aim was to evaluate the effectiveness of the harmonic scalpel in patients undergoing total thyroidectomy. Methods In this study, 90 patients were randomized into group A (classic technique of tying and knots) and group B (harmonic scalpel). We recorded the following: age, sex, pathology, thyroid weight, hemostatic technique, duration of operation, change in calcemia (ΔCa), change in hematocrit (ΔHt), change in hemoglobin (ΔHgb), change in white blood cell count (ΔWBC), vocal motility, operative difficulty, postoperative vocal alteration, postoperative pain, complications, blood in the drains, operating time, mass of gland excised per minute, and hospitalization. Results Differences (p < .05) were observed concerning duration of surgery, operative difficulty, postoperative pain, hospitalization, ΔWBC, and quantity of gland removed per minute. No recurrent laryngeal nerve (RLN) palsies were observed. Conclusions Use of the Harmonic Scalpel in total thyroidectomy is more effective than the clamp‐and‐tie technique: the duration of surgery, intraoperative difficulty, postoperative pain, and hospitalization are reduced. Both techniques are equivalent concerning RLN injuries, postoperative vocal alterations, and blood loss. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Head Neck, 2010