INFLUENCE OF THE ORIGINAL DISEASE, RACE, AND CENTER ON THE OUTCOME OF KIDNEY TRANSPLANTATION

Abstract

The low graft survival rate in black recipients (36 ± 2% at 1 year) as compared with the graft survival rate in white recipients (48 ± 1%) might be secondary to a higher incidence of vascular lesions, inducing hypertensive disease, in blacks than in whites. The relative frequency of malignant hypertension in black recipients was six times that of white recipients, and recipients with malignant hypertension had a significant lower graft survival rate (43 ± 2%) than recipients with glomerulonephritis (54 ± 1%). In addition, patients with vascular lesions (diabetes, malignant hypertension, and glomerulonephritis) showed significantly lower graft survival rates in black than in white recipients, in contrast to patients with primary tubular or interstitial lesions (polycystic kidneys and pyelonephritis), who showed similar graft survival rates in blacks and whites. Only a small fraction of this racial effect could be traced back to the higher incidence of Lewis-negative phenotypes in black recipients and a similar beneficial effect of transfusions, on graft survival, was observed in both black and white recipients. The effects on graft survival of age (6%), race (9%), and transfusions (18%) were significant in good (A) and poor (B) centers. No overlap between A and B centers was observed for any of these three parameters when analyzed separately. However, when the cumulative effects of these three risk parameters were analyzed together a partial overlap appeared, i.e., higher graft survival rates were observed in low-risk recipients that received transplants in B centers than in high-risk recipients that received transplants in A centers. Consequently, the selection of the recipient may play a role in the overall results of different transplantation units, leading to their classification into A or B centers, but cannot explain all of the differences between A and B centers.