Contested paradigms of ‘viability’ in redistributive land reform: perspectives from southern Africa
Open Access
- 22 January 2010
- journal article
- Published by Informa UK Limited in The Journal of Peasant Studies
- Vol. 37 (1), 31-66
- https://doi.org/10.1080/03066150903498739
Abstract
‘Viability’ is a key term in debates about land redistribution in southern African and beyond. It is often used to connote ‘successful’ and ‘sustainable’– but what is meant by viability in relation to land reform, and how have particular conceptions of viability informed state policies and planning approaches over time? How have such notions influenced the contested politics of land and agriculture? In southern Africa policy debates have tended to focus narrowly on farm productivity and economic returns, and an implicit normative model is the large-scale commercial farm. Through a review of land reform experiences in South Africa, Namibia and Zimbabwe, this paper critically interrogates this influential but under-examined notion. It examines contrasting framings of viability derived from neo-classical economics, new institutional economics, livelihoods approaches (both developmentalist and welfarist), radical political economy and Marxism, and their influence in southern Africa. Through a discussion of alternative framings of viability, the paper aims to help shift policy debates away from a narrow, technocratic economism, a perspective often backed by powerful interests, towards a more plural view, one more compatible with small-scale, farming-based livelihoods.ESRKeywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Peasants Make Their Own History, But Not Just as They Please . . .Journal of Agrarian Change, 2008
- ‘Willing buyer, willing seller’: South Africa's failed experiment in market-led agrarian reformThird World Quarterly, 2007
- ‘Changing Before Our Very Eyes’: Agrarian Questions and the Politics of Land in Capitalism TodayJournal of Agrarian Change, 2003
- Searching for a Weapon of Mass Production in Rural Africa: Unconvincing Arguments for Land ReformJournal of Agrarian Change, 2003
- Neo‐Classical Neo‐Populism 25 Years On: Déjà Vu and Déjà Passé. Towards a CritiqueJournal of Agrarian Change, 2003
- Land Reform: Taking a Long(er) ViewJournal of Agrarian Change, 2002
- Evolving Themes in Rural Development 1950s‐2000sDevelopment Policy Review, 2001
- Land Reform, Growth and Equity: Emerging Evidence from Zimbabwe's Resettlement ProgrammeJournal of Southern African Studies, 1999
- Setting the agenda: a critique of the World Bank's rural restructuring programme for South AfricaJournal of Southern African Studies, 1996
- State, peasantry and resettlement in ZimbabweReview of African Political Economy, 1994