Prion protein remodelling confers an immediate phenotypic switch

Abstract

The prospects of limiting the spread of transmissible spongiform encephalopathies such as Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease depend in part on identifying the most infectious forms of the prions that carry the diseases. A study of modified scrapie prions shows that clusters of 14 to 28 prion proteins are the most infectious and that clusters of less than six molecules have virtually no infectivity. That could have implications for the treatment of diseases such as Alzheimer's and Parkinson's, characterized by deposition of prion-related amyloid fibrils. It's possible that efforts to alleviate symptoms by destabilizing these large protein aggregates might make things worse by producing smaller, more infective particles. Two other papers in this issue tackle fundamental aspects of the biology of prions and amyloid fibrils. The conversion of the yeast protein Sup35 to its prion form does not need to happen during the synthesis of Sup35 — mature and fully functional molecules can readily join a prion seed. This remodelling of the mature protein is accompanied by the immediate loss of its activity. And a study of a ‘designed’ amyloid fibril made from ribonuclease A reveals that amyloid containing native-like molecules can retain enzyme activity. This involves a domain swap with the neighbouring protein, and supports the ‘zipper-spine model’ for β-amyloid structures. In a variety of systems, proteins have been linked to processes historically limited to nucleic acids, such as infectivity and inheritance1,2. These atypical proteins, termed prions3, lack sequence homology but are collectively defined by their capacity to adopt multiple physical and therefore functional states in vivo. Newly synthesized prion protein generally adopts the form already present in the cell, and this in vivo folding bias directs the near faithful transmission of the corresponding phenotypic state1,2. Switches between the prion and non-prion phenotypes can occur in vivo2; however, the fate of existing protein during these transitions and its effects on the emergence of new traits remain major unanswered questions. Here, we determine the changes in protein-state that induce phenotypic switching for the yeast prion Sup35/[PSI+]. We show that the prion form does not need to be specified by an alternate misfolding pathway initiated during Sup35 synthesis but instead can be accessed by mature protein. This remodelling of protein from one stable form to another is accompanied by the loss of Sup35 activity, evoking a rapid change in cellular phenotype within a single cell cycle.