Quantifying a Severe Discrepancy: A Critical Analysis
- 1 November 1981
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Learning Disability Quarterly
- Vol. 4 (4), 359-371
- https://doi.org/10.2307/1510737
Abstract
The four basic methods of quantifying severe academic discrepancy - [Formula: see text] grade level deviation, expectancy formula, standard-score comparisons, and regression analysis — are evaluated in terms of: ease of administration, measurement errors, regression effects, years in school, changes in variation of achievement scores at different grades, comparability of norms, incidence, and systematic and consistent treatment of IQ/achievement interrelationship. Results indicate that both the deviation from grade level and the expectancy formulas fail to consider almost all critical variables. While the IQ/standard-score method takes into account several of the factors, it does not adequately consider regression effects. The a priori analysis indicates that the regression equation approach considers almost all the criterion variables with the exception of years in school. Hence based upon critical statistical and measurement concepts, the authors tentatively conclude that the latter approach is superior to the other quantification methods analyzed. It is emphasized, however, that such aspects as incidence and student characteristics can only be empirically determined.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- An Evaluation of the Regression Discrepancy Method for Identifying Children With Learning DisabilitiesThe Journal of Special Education, 1980
- Toward Defining Discrepancies for Specific Learning Disabilities: An Analysis and AlternativesLearning Disability Quarterly, 1979
- Educational UnderachievementJournal of Learning Disabilities, 1979
- A Formula-based Classification of Learning Disabled ChildrenJournal of Learning Disabilities, 1978
- Learning disability as related to infrequent punishment and limited participation in delay of reinforcement tasksJournal of School Psychology, 1975
- The Z-Score Discrepancy Method for Identifying Reading Disabled ChildrenJournal of Learning Disabilities, 1975