The effect of combining antitubulin agents on differentiated and undifferentiated human colon cancer cells

Abstract

The cytotoxicity of sequential combinations of a taxoid [paclitaxel (TAX) or docetaxel (TXT)] with a vinca alkaloid [vinoreibine (NVB)] was compared in differentiated and undifferentiated HT29-D4 cells. Agents were titrated from low doses inducing no modification of microtubule network to high doses corresponding to the clinically relevant concentrations that block mitosis. For undifferentiated cells, the sequential combination NVB/TAX was more efficient than TAX/NVB (22% cell survival versus 37% for 5 nM TAX and NVB). Surprisingly, we successively obtained synergism for low doses of both compounds [NVB (1–5 nM) and TAX (1–15 nM)], then additivity and finally antagonism when one of the compounds was at the concentration inducing mitotic block. The three patterns of results were also obtained with NVB/TXT combinations. For the synergistic combinations at the lowest concentrations, cytotoxicity occurred by apoptosis following mitosis. For differentiated cells, the most cytotoxic combinations were 1 μM TAX or TXT for 3 days followed by 1 μM NVB for 3 days, and 0.75 nM TAX or TXT for 9 days followed by 1 μM NVB for 3 days, the latter producing synergistic effects. Cytotoxicity occurred by apoptosis for the two states of differentiation. Major differences depending on cell phenotype were demonstrated: low sensitivity of differentiated cells to antitubulin agents and the difference in apoptotic pathways since mitosis is not involved in differentiated cells.