The molecular mechanism of the bicarbonate effect at the plastoquinone reductase site of photosynthesis

Abstract

It has been known for some time that bicarbonate reverses the inhibition, by formate under HCO₃ ^--depletion conditions, of electron transport in thylakoid membranes. It has been shown that the major effect is on the electron acceptor side of photosystem II, at the site of plastoquinone reduction. After presenting a historical introduction, and a minireview of the bicarbonate effect, we present a hypothesis on how HCO₃ ^- functions in vivo as (a) a proton donor to the plastoquinone reductase site in the D1-D2 protein; and (b) a ligand to Fe²⁺ in the Q_A-Fe-Q_B complex that keeps the D1-D2 proteins in their proper functional conformation. They key points of the hypothesis are: (1) HCO₃ ^- forms a salt bridge between Fe²⁺ and the D2 protein. The carboxyl group of HCO₃ ^- is a bidentate ligand to Fe²⁺, while the hydroxyl group H-bonds to a protein residue. (2) A second HCO₃ ^- is involved in protonating a histidine near the Q_B site to stabilize the negative charge on Q_B. HCO₃ ^- provides a rapidly available source of H⁺ for this purpose. (3) After donation of a H⁺, CO₃ ^2- is replaced by another HCO₃ ^-. The high pKa of CO₃ ^2- ensures rapid reprotonation from the bulk phase. (4) An intramembrane pool of HCO₃ ^- is in equilibrium with a large number of low affinity sites. This pool is a H⁺ buffering domain functionally connecting the external bulk phase with the quinones. The low affinity sites buffer the intrathylakoid [HCO₃ ^-] against fluctuations in the intracellular CO₂. (5) Low pH and high ionic strength are suggested to disrupt the HCO₃ ^- salt bridge between Fe²⁺ and D₂. The resulting conformational change exposes the intramembrane HCO₃ ^- pool and low affinity sites to the bulk phase. Two contrasting hypotheses for the action of formate are: (a) it functions to remove bicarbonate, and the low electron transport left in such samples is due to the left-over (or endogenous) bicarbonate in the system; or (b) bicarbonate is less of an inhibitor and so appears to relieve the inhibition by formate. Hypothesis (a) implies that HCO₃ ^- is an essential requirement for electron transport through the plastoquinones (bound plastoquinones Q_A and Q_B and the plastoquinone pool) of photosystem II. Hypothesis (b) implies that HCO₃ ^- does not play any significant role in vivo. Our conclusion is that hypothesis (a) is correct and HCO₃ ^- is an essential requirement for electron transport on the electron acceptor side of PS II. This is based on several observations: (i) since HCO₃ ^-, not CO₂, is the active species involved (Blubaugh and Govindjee 1986), the calculated concentration of this species (220 μM at pH 8, pH of the stroma) is much higher than the calculated dissociation constant (Kd) of 35–60 μM; thus, the likelihood of bound HCO₃ ^- in ambient air is high; (ii) studies on HCO₃ ^- effect in thylakoid samples with different chlorophyll concentrations suggest that the “left-over” (or “endogenous”) electron flow in bicarbonate-depleted chloroplasts is due to “left-over” (or endogenous) HCO₃ ^- remaining bound to the system (Blubaugh 1987).