Comparison of the conformation and orientation of alamethicin and melittin in lipid membranes

Abstract

The secondary structure of alamethicin in lipid membranes below and above the lipid phase transition temperature Tt is determined by Raman spectroscopy and circular dichroism (CD) measurements. In both cases structural data are obtained by fitting the experimental spectra by a superposition of the spectra of 15 reference proteins of known three-dimensional structure. According to the Raman experiments, in a lipid bilayer above Tt alamethicin is helical from residue 1 to 12, whereas below Tt the helix extends from residue 1 to 16. The remaining C-terminal part is nonhelical up to the end residue 20 both above and below Tt. A considerable lower helix content is derived from CD, namely, 38% and 46% above and below Tt, respectively, in agreement with several reported values for CD in the literature. It is shown that the commonly used set of CD spectra of water-soluble reference proteins is unsuitable to describe the CD spectra of alamethicin correctly. Therefore the secondary structure of alamethicin as derived from CD measurements is at the present state of analysis unreliable. In contrast to the case of alamethicin, the CD spectra of melittin in lipid membranes are correctly described by the reference protein spectra. The helix content of melittin is determined thereby to be 72% in lipid membranes above Tt and 75% below Tt. The data are in accord with a structure where the hydrophobic part of melittin adopts a bent helix as determined recently by Raman spectroscopy [Vogel, H., and Jahnig, F. (1986) Biophys. J. 50, 573]. The orientational order parameters of the helical parts of alamethicin and of melittin in a lipid membrane are deduced from the difference between a corresponding CD spectrum of a polypeptide in planar multibilayers and that in lipid vesicles. The presented method for determining helix order parameters is new and may be generally applicable to other membrane proteins. The orientation of the helical part of both polypeptides depends on the physical state of the lipid bilayer at maximal membrane hydration and in the ordered lipid state furthermore on the degree of membrane hydration. Under conditions where alamethicin and melittin are incorporated in an aggregated form in a fluid lipid membrane at maximal water content the helical segments are oriented preferentially parallel to the membrane normal. Cooling such lipid membranes to a temperature below Tt changes the orientation of the helical part of alamethicin as well as melittin toward the membrane plane. On the contrary in dried planar membranes at 2% (w/w) water content both polypeptide molecules are oriented with their helical parts preferentially parallel to the membrane normal, similar to the case of fluid lipid membranes.