Is pathological development part of normal cognitive neuropsychology?—A rejoinder to marcel
- 1 January 1990
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Cognitive Neuropsychology
- Vol. 7 (1), 49-55
- https://doi.org/10.1080/02643299008253435
Abstract
The paper to which Marcel is replying can be summarised rather briefly. We report the case of a boy (TA) who, despite gross global cognitive impairment, reads and writes Italian extremely well (at the level of bidirectional speech/print transcoding). Marcel can find no flaw with our basic methology, and hence no fault with our data per se. The arguments at issue concern solely the theoretical interpretation of such findings, and we shall accordingly follow Marcel to this high ground. Our report was intended as a case-study in both senses of that term: n = 1, and a set of assumptions about how to relate developmental deficits to normal cognitive architectures. In wanting to reject this particular study, Marcel well realises that he is attacking an entire research paradigm. If our bambino is thrown out with Marcel's bathwater, then a lot of other people's babies will follow the same route. This is admittedly no defence to Marcel's critique, but one should keep in mind the scope of his attack. The principal thrust of Marcel's argument is that our data are just not relevant to the proto-theory we espouse; a subsidiary claim is that the theory itself is underdeveloped. Although these points are, of course, inter-related, we shall initially take them separately.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Does the midsagittal plane play any privileged role in “left” neglect?Cognitive Neuropsychology, 1989
- A Specialization for Speech PerceptionScience, 1989
- From Neuropsychology to Mental StructurePublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,1988
- Awareness of phonological segments and reading ability in Italian childrenApplied Psycholinguistics, 1988
- AN ISLET OF ABILITY IN AUTISTIC CHILDREN: A RESEARCH NOTEJournal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 1983
- Conscious and unconscious perception: An approach to the relations between phenomenal experience and perceptual processesCognitive Psychology, 1983
- Machine recognition of constrained hand printed devanagariPattern Recognition, 1977
- A theoretical approach for character recognition based on phenomenological attributesInternational Journal of Man-Machine Studies, 1974