Judicial Biography and the Behavioral Persuasion
- 1 September 1971
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in American Political Science Review
- Vol. 65 (3), 704-715
- https://doi.org/10.2307/1955515
Abstract
This paper appraises the relationship between judicial biography and judicial behavior research in two ways: (1) conceptually, by comparing them as modes of inquiry; and (2) empirically, by making an inventory of the behavioral content of 15. leading judicial biographies. The central theme is that judicial biographies and judicial behavior research are complementary. Conceptually, they have important common premises and problems as well as major differences. Empirically, judicial biographies also offer considerable insight into judicial behavior. Using generous standards, the inventory of 15 biographies derived 2,232 behavioral-like propositions in eight categories of behavioral research. More importantly, the biographies suggest a substantial number of hypotheses worthy of empirical investigation and validation. When viewed as case studies in judicial politics, judicial biographies thus become related to behavioral inquiry. And their strengths and weaknesses fall into place as reflecting properties generally associated with case study as a mode of political analysis.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Essays in Sociological Explanation.American Sociological Review, 1971
- A Map for the Analysis of Personality and PoliticsJournal of Social Issues, 1968
- Public Law and Judicial BehaviorThe Journal of Politics, 1968
- Role Theory and the Supreme CourtThe Journal of Politics, 1968
- Personality and PoliticsAmerican Behavioral Scientist, 1967
- Social Backgrounds and Judicial Decisions: Notes for a TheoryThe Journal of Politics, 1967
- Judicial Biography and the United States Supreme Court: A Bibliographical AppraisalAmerican Journal of Legal History, 1967
- Judicial Behavior: Themes and VariationsPublic Administration Review, 1966
- Jackson's Judicial Philosophy: An Exploration in Value AnalysisAmerican Political Science Review, 1965
- Harlan Fiske Stone: Pillar of the LawThe University of Chicago Law Review, 1957