Panoptic Reason and the Search for Totality: A Critical Assessment of the Critical Systems Perspective
- 1 July 1992
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Human Relations
- Vol. 45 (7), 637-657
- https://doi.org/10.1177/001872679204500701
Abstract
This paper reviews the main claims and assumptions of the critical systems perspective (CSP) and subjects them to vigorous criticism. It is argued that CSP is flawed on philosophical and sociological grounds. Philosophically, CSP is criticized for its use of ideological premises which are unsusceptible to scientific criticism, for its unrealistic assumptions concerning the alleged unitary nature of organizations and society, for an essentialist conception of human beings, and for its inability to distinguish between different types of systems research. Sociologically, CSP's inadequate conceptualization of power in organizations is discussed. CSP also espouses an apolitical conception of organizational actors, and fails to appreciate the inherently open nature of social systems which is manifested mainly through the emergence of unintended consequences. It is argued here that all the above deficiencies emanate from two fundamental premises: the panoptic status CSP accords to reason, and the totalizing nature of CSP's discourse. Both premises are criticized in this paper as indefensible.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- The boundaries between critical systems thinking and interpretive systems thinking: Critical comment on Flood and Ulrich's ?Testament to Conversations on Critical Systems Thinking?Systemic Practice and Action Research, 1990
- Systems thinking and critique. I. What is critique?Systemic Practice and Action Research, 1990
- Beyond a System of Systems MethodologiesJournal of the Operational Research Society, 1990
- The critical kernel in modern systems thinkingSystemic Practice and Action Research, 1990
- A new decade, a new spiritSystemic Practice and Action Research, 1990
- Power-ideology matrix in social systems controlSystemic Practice and Action Research, 1990
- Testament to conversations on critical systems thinking between two systems practitionersSystemic Practice and Action Research, 1990
- Methodological foundations of systems methodologiesSystemic Practice and Action Research, 1988
- Towards a System of Systems MethodologiesJournal of the Operational Research Society, 1984
- Organisational control and the problem of orderSocial Science Information, 1977