Comparison of the in vivo and in vitro antibacterial properties of antiseptic mouthrinses containing chlorhexidine, alexidine, cetyl pyridinium chloride and hexetidine

Abstract

A study was carried out to compare the antibacterial properties of four cationic antiseptics, three of which are available as commercial mouthrinse preparations. Minimum inhibitory concentrations for alexidine, cetyl pyridinium chloride, chlorhexidine gluconate and hexetidine against a range of standard test organisms, were determined by tube dilution, Similar values for Oxford staphylococcus were then obtained in Dubos medium to which protein as yeast, or food extract, or serum was added in doubling dilutions to 16%. Salivary bacterial counts after a single rinse with the antiseptics 01 water throughout the day were measured in 10 subjects together with the duration of any residual antiseptic activity in the saliva. All antiseptics were effective at low concentrations against the organisms tested but the minimum inhibitory concentration values for hexetidine were the highest. Food extract and serum markedly increased the minimum inhibitory concentration values of all antiseptics, although alexidine and hexetidine were the least affected in percentage terms. The activity of a 1% povidone iodine preparation, used for comparison, was almost completely vitiated. An immediate significant fall in salivary bacterial counts was produced by the cationic antiseptics. Return to pre-rinse levels was seen for hexetidine after 90 min, cetyl pyridinium chloride after 3 hours, alexidine after 5 hours and chlorhexidine gluconate after 7 hours. Residual salivary antibacterial activity remained to 90 min for cetyl pyridinium chloride, to 3 hours for alexidine and alexidine and to 5 hours for chlorhexidine gluconate. The antibacterial properties measured, in particular the duration of effect in vivo, may be relevant to the anti-plaque activity of cationic antiseptics.