Calcimimetics versus Vitamin D: What Are Their Relative Roles?

Abstract

A strict control of secondary hyperparathyroidism in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) is indicated to avoid serious complications linked to osteitis fibrosa and other parathyroid-hormone (PTH)-related bodily disturbances. However, such a control is often achieved only at the price of unacceptably high plasma calcium and phosphorus levels and the risk of soft tissue calcification, even when using the novel, so-called ‘non-hypercalcemic’ vitamin D analogs. The advent of a new class of drugs, the calcimimetics, should allow a more adequate control of the disturbed calcium-phosphorus metabolism in CKD patients. In my opinion, the calcimimetics will not replace currently used medications but will be a valuable supplement to presently available treatment options for this major complication in patients with renal failure.