Personal assistance—direct payments or alternative public service. Does it matter for the promotion of user control?
- 1 May 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Disability & Society
- Vol. 20 (3), 247-260
- https://doi.org/10.1080/09687590500060562
Abstract
Personal assistance organised as direct payments is seen as an important means for securing user control and freeing disabled people from their reliance on welfare professionals and unpaid carers. The hypothesis put forward in the article is that just looking at whether personal assistance is organised as direct payments or as an alternative service represents an overly restricted approach to judge how the user’s preferences are taken care of. By comparing models of personal assistance in the US, the UK, Sweden and Norway it will show that several other factors influence user control. In the final part of the article the question is raised as to whether paternalism is always negative for welfare service users. Since the users constitute a broad group it might be questioned if the assumption of the service users as rational, well informed and competent to make the best choices is always valid.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Friend or Foe? Towards a Critical Assessment of Direct PaymentsCritical Social Policy, 2004
- The Future Challenge for Direct PaymentsDisability & Society, 2002
- Making connections: the relevance of the social model of disability for people with learning difficultiesBritish Journal of Learning Disabilities, 2001
- Commissioning for Quality: Ten Years of Social Care Markets in EnglandJournal of Social Policy, 2001
- Money talks? Competing discourses in the implementation of direct paymentsCritical Social Policy, 2000
- Home care allowances: Good for many but not for allPractice, 2000
- State Social Work and Social Citizenship in Britain: From Clientelism to ConsumerismThe British Journal of Social Work, 1999
- Postmodernism and Social Policy: A Great Leap Backwards?Journal of Social Policy, 1994
- Personal Assistance Services: The Hub of the Policy Wheel for Community Integration of People with Severe Physical DisabilitiesPolicy Studies Journal, 1993
- The movement for independent living: An evaluation and critiqueSocial Science & Medicine, 1983