Bone and Muscle Development During Puberty in Girls: A Seven-Year Longitudinal Study

Abstract

The growth of lean mass precedes that of bone mass, suggesting that muscle plays an important role in the growth of bone. However, to date, no study has directly followed the growth of bone and muscle size through puberty and into adulthood. This study aimed to test the hypothesis that the growth of muscle size precedes that of bone size (width and length) and mass during puberty. Bone and muscle properties were measured using pQCT and DXA in 258 healthy girls at baseline (mean age, 11.2 yr) and 1-, 2-, 3–4- and 7-yr follow-up. Growth trends as a function of time relative to menarche were determined from prepuberty to early adulthood for tibial length (TL), total cross-sectional area (tCSA), cortical CSA (cCSA), total BMC (tBMC), cortical volumetric BMD (cBMD), and muscle CSA (mCSA) in hierarchical models. The timings of the peak growth velocities for these variables were calculated. Seventy premenopausal adults, comprising a subset of the girl's mothers (mean age, 41.5 yr), were included for comparative purposes. In contrast to our hypothesis, the growth velocity of mCSA peaked 1 yr later than that of tibial outer dimensions (TL and tCSA) and slightly earlier than tBMC. Whereas TL ceased to increase 2 yr after menarche, tCSA, cCSA, tBMC, and mCSA continued to increase and were still significantly lower than adult values at the age of 18 yr (all p < 0.01). The results do not support the view that muscle force drives the growth of bone size during puberty.