Testing the assumptions of rationality, continuity and symmetry when applying discrete choice experiments in health care
- 1 January 2001
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Applied Economics Letters
- Vol. 8 (1), 59-63
- https://doi.org/10.1080/135048501750041312
Abstract
In the absence of revealed preference behaviour, economists use experimental techniques to estimate welfare changes. Such an approach relies on a number of assumptions concerning individual behaviour. This paper uses a discrete choice experiment to test three of these assumptions – rationality, continuity and symmetry. The experiment was carried out with users of a rheumatology clinic in the Grampian area of Scotland and was concerned with preferences for a specialist-nurse-led clinic. Two tests of ‘rationality’ were included in the experiment. Tests were carried out to see if respondents always chose on the basis of their preferred staffing, suggesting discontinuities in the utility function. The axiom of symmetry was tested using a split sample design, with respondents divided into two groups. Each group received a different questionnaire that varied with respect to the order of the choices. Over 30% of respondents provided at least one ‘irrational’ response. Such respondents did not differ significantly in their characteristics from ‘rational’ responses, suggesting that utility estimates would not be biased if this group were excluded from the analysis. Seventeen per cent of respondents showed signs of having non-compensatory utility functions. Evidence was found to support the axiom of symmetry. Future work should explore the axioms of rationality and continuity in more detail.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Applying conjoint analysis in economic evaluations: an application to menorrhagiaApplied Economics, 2000
- Contingent Valuation Versus Choice Experiments: Estimating the Benefits of Environmentally Sensitive Areas in ScotlandJournal of Agricultural Economics, 1998
- Estimating Stated Preferences with Rated-Pair Data: Environmental, Health, and Employment Effects of Energy ProgramsJournal of Environmental Economics and Management, 1997
- The expanding role of the nurse in rheumatologyRheumatology, 1997
- The Disutility of Time Spent on the United Kingdom's National Health Service Waiting ListsThe Journal of Human Resources, 1995
- Internal Consistency of ChoiceEconometrica, 1993
- Contingent Valuation of Time Spent on NHS Waiting ListsThe Economic Journal, 1990
- Welfare Evaluations in Contingent Valuation Experiments with Discrete ResponsesAmerican Journal of Agricultural Economics, 1984
- A New Approach to Consumer TheoryJournal of Political Economy, 1966
- A Study of Irrational JudgmentsJournal of Political Economy, 1957