Heritability of body size in a natural population of the Great Tit (Parus major) and its relation to age and environmental conditions during growth

Abstract

Summary: We have analysed data on weight and tarsus length collected during a long-term study of natural populations of Great Tits to evaluate the relative importance of genetic variation in body size. Some of our data were collected over a 25-year period, and therefore include a relatively large sample of naturally occurring environmental conditions. An overall heritability estimate calculated from the uncorrected mean weights of breeding birds amounts to 0·5. This estimate is unlikely to be influenced by resemblance in environmental conditions between relatives. Heritability estimates based on the size of fledglings vary between zero and the value for adults, depending on the environmental conditions during growth. If the feeding conditions for the nestlings are poor, no resemblance between parents and offspring is observed. Selection against small nestlings acts strongly on the environmental variance. This is concluded from the higher heritability estimates in the same cohorts after survival for at least three months after fledging, compared to measurements on nestlings. Such selection acting differentially on the genetic and environmental components of the phenotypic variance has important consequences for our ability to make predictions of phenotypic change from measured natural selection. Nevertheless, the amount of genetic variation would allow rapid response should selection on adult size occur.