Inefficacy of Penicillin V in Acute Laryngitis in Adults

Abstract

Patients with acute laryngitis following an upper respiratory tract infection are often treated with antibiotics for their voice complaints, although, to our knowledge, the effect of such therapy has not been examined. In the present study, comprising 100 adults with laryngitis, the rate of resolution of vocal symptoms, as estimated from voice recordings or subjectively by the patients, was the same in patients who received penicillin V (pcV) as in those who received placebo. Similarly, the degree of rhinorrhea/nasal congestion and cough was not significantly influenced by pcV treatment. At the acute visit, nasopharyngeal cultures revealed Branhamella catarrhalis in 50%, Hemophilus influenzae in 15% and Streptococcus pneumoniae in 1% of the patients; the rate of elimination of these bacteria was the same in the pcV as in the placebo group. Thus, while suggesting that B catarrhalis and H influenzae are important for the pathogenesis of the disorder, our results do not provide support for the use of pcV in acute laryngitis.