Rationalist assumptions in cross-media comparisons of computer-mediated communication
- 1 March 1991
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Behaviour & Information Technology
- Vol. 10 (2), 153-172
- https://doi.org/10.1080/01449299108924279
Abstract
Users' comparisons between computer-mediated communication (CMC) and other forms of communication are of theoretical interest and have important implications for system design and implementation. This paper outlines the prevalent systems-rationalist perspective on CMC, which sees the medium primarily as an efficient channel for information transfer in specific organizational tasks, and critically reviews the evidence that studies of users' perceptions and media preferences offer for this generalized view. In advocating a widening of our perspective on CMC, a field study is described in which electronic mail users within a large commercial telecommunications company were invited to compare eight different communication activities, using repertory grid technique. From a total of 91 user-generated constructs, five principal dimensions were identified that accounted for users' discriminations among the different activities. Electronic mailing was construed as being similar to written activities (such as note-writing) on some dimensions (e.g., ‘ asynchrony’, ‘ emotional quality’ but similar to spoken, face-to-face communication on other dimensions such as ‘ spontaneity’. The results suggest that the group of users construed CMC mainly in terms of its attributes as a medium for conversation and social interaction. There was no evidence of spontaneous task-related media comparisons. These results together with findings from other studies are discussed in terms of rationalist and symbolic interactionist perspectives on CMC. Implications for system design are also considered.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Experiments in group decision making, 3: disinhibition, deindividuation, and group process in pen name and real name computer conferencesDecision Support Systems, 1989
- Who's joking? The information system at playInteracting with Computers, 1989
- Productivity enhancement from computer-mediated communication: a systems contingency approachCommunications of the ACM, 1988
- Computer-Mediated Communication and Organizational InnovationJournal of Communication, 1987
- Group and computer-mediated discussion effects in risk decision making.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1987
- ?Anonymity is part of the magic?: Individual manipulation of computer-mediated communication contextsQualitative Sociology, 1987
- Experiments in Group Decision Making Communication Process and Outcome in Face-to-Face Versus Computerized ConferencesHuman Communication Research, 1986
- Social psychological aspects of computer-mediated communication.American Psychologist, 1984
- Social Analyses of Computing: Theoretical Perspectives in Recent Empirical ResearchACM Computing Surveys, 1980
- Computer conferencing: Assessing the social impact of a new communications mediumTechnological Forecasting and Social Change, 1977