Gene talk in sociobiology
- 1 April 1992
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Epistemology
- Vol. 6 (2), 109-163
- https://doi.org/10.1080/02691729208578649
Abstract
Terminology within the biological sciences gets its import not just from semantic meaning, but also from the way it functions within the rhetorics of the various disciplinary practices. The ‘sociobiology’ of human behavior inherits three distinct rhetorics from the genetic disciplines. Sociobiologists use population genetic, biometrical genetic, and molecular genetic rhetorics, without acknowledging the conceptual and experimental constraints that are assumed by geneticists. The eclectic blending of these three rhetorics obscures important differences of context and meaning. Sociobiologists use foundational terms in genetics, such as ‘gene’, ‘fitness’, ‘evolution’, ‘heritability’, ‘trait’ and ‘polygenic inheritance’, in starkly different ways from geneticists, while basing their analysis of human behavior on the implied authority of genetics. As a free‐floating ‘gene talk’ moves across different disciplinary contexts, and before different audiences, it takes the form of an over‐simplified and misleading arch‐determinism. The result is widespread application of vague, incomplete, and distorted biological theory. If most sociobiologists, do not deliberately promote biological determinism, still less a political agenda, there is ample evidence that they misconstrue the implications of the genetic language that they borrow.Keywords
This publication has 94 references indexed in Scilit:
- Polite DNA: Functional density and functional compatibility in genomesJournal of Molecular Evolution, 1986
- Compositional constraints and genome evolutionJournal of Molecular Evolution, 1986
- On the relation between genetic and environmental variability in animalsJournal of Molecular Evolution, 1982
- Evolutionarily stable dispersal strategiesJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1980
- Admixture Studies and the Detection of SelectionScience, 1973
- Geometry for the selfish herdJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1971
- The moulding of senescence by natural selectionJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1966
- The genetical evolution of social behaviour. IIJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1964
- The genetical evolution of social behaviour. IJournal of Theoretical Biology, 1964
- XV.—The Correlation between Relatives on the Supposition of Mendelian Inheritance.Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 1919