Multiple Roles and Successes in Public Bioethics: A Response to the Public Forum Critique of Bioethics Commissions
- 1 June 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Project MUSE in Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal
- Vol. 16 (2), 173-188
- https://doi.org/10.1353/ken.2006.0010
Abstract
ANational bioethics commissions have been critiqued for a variety of structural, procedural, and political aspects of their work. A more recent critique published by Dzur and Levin uses political philosophy to constructively critique the work of national bioethics commissions as public deliberative forums. However, this public forum critique of bioethics commissions ignores empirical research in political science and normative claims that suggest that advisory commissions can and should have diverse of functions beyond that of being public forums. The present paper argues that the public forum critique too narrowly considers the roles that bioethics commissions can play in public bioethics and ignores the moral obligation of commissions to fulfill their mandates. Evaluations of commissions must consider that these institutions can serve in capacities other than those of a public deliberative forum and use additional measures to evaluate the multiple roles and successes of bioethics commissions in public policy.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Blue Ribbons, Black Boxes: Toward a Better Understanding of Presidential CommissionsPresidential Studies Quarterly, 2004
- Passing on the Right: Conservative Bioethics is Closer Than it AppearsPublished by Cambridge University Press (CUP) ,2004
- Some Initial Reflections on NBACKennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 2002
- Engaging the public in policy development: The national bioethics advisory commission report on research involving persons with mental disorders that may affect decisionmaking capacityAccountability in Research, 1999
- Truth or Consequences: The Role of Philosophers in Policy-MakingEthics, 1987
- The Ambiguous Legacy of American Presidential CommissionsThe Public Historian, 1985