TheEichner/StorarDecision: A Year's Perspective

Abstract

On March 31,1981, the New York Gurt of Appeals handed down its decision in the consolidated cases of Brother Joseph Fox and John Storar. The Eichner case was generally well known, having excited considerable national publicity both before and after the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York handed down its opinion on March 17,1980. TheStorarcase,) conversely, was not as well known and was consolidated with the Eichner case, in the words of the Court of Appeals, because future similar cases would arise. As will be discussed more fully in this article, the consolidation of these two markedly dissimilar cases not only has created confusion, but also has served to obscure the position taken by the court of Appeals relative to other similar cases both in New York and other jurisdictions.Brother Joseph Fox was an 83 year old member of a Catholic religious order who enjoyed good health until he suffered cardiac arrest during the performance of a hernia operation. As a result of the cardiac arrest, he became anoxic, suffered permanent brain damage, and became respirator-dependent.