Secondary instability of wall-bounded shear flows

Abstract

An analysis is given of a secondary instability that obtains in a wide class of wall-bounded parallel shear flows, including plane Poiseuille flow, plane Couette flow, flat-plate boundary layers, and pipe Poiseuille flow. In these flows it is shown that two-dimensional finite-amplitude waves are (exponentially) unstable to infinitesimal three-dimensional disturbances. This secondary instability seems to be the prototype of transitional instability in these flows in that it has the characteristic (convective) timescales observed in the typical transitions. In the case of plane Poiseuille flow, two-dimensional nonlinear equilibria and quasi-equilibria exist, and the stability of the secondary flow is determined by a three-dimensional linear eigenvalue calculation. In flows without equilibria (e.g. pipe flow), a time-dependent stability analysis is performed by direct spectral numerical calculation of the incompressible three-dimensional Navier–Stokes equations.The energetics and vorticity dynamics of the instability are discussed. It is shown that the two-dimensional wave mediates the transfer of energy from the mean flow to the three-dimensional perturbation but does not directly provide energy to the disturbance. The instability is of an inviscid character as it persists to high Reynolds numbers and grows on convective timescales. Maximum vorticity (inflexion-point) arguments predict some features of the instability like phase-locking of the two-dimensional and three-dimensional waves, but they do not explain its essential three-dimensionality. The inviscid vorticity dynamics of the instability shows that vortext-stretching and tilting effects are both required to explain the persistent exponential growth. The instability is not centrifugal in nature.The three-dimensional instability requires that a threshold two-dimensional amplitude be achieved (about 1% of the centreline velocity in plane Poiseuille flow): the growth rates are relatively insensitive to amplitude for moderate two-dimensional amplitudes. With moderate two-dimensional amplitudes, the critical Reynolds numbers for substantial three-dimensional growth are about 1000 in plane Poiseuille and Couette flows and several thousand in pipe Poiseuille flow. The asymptotic (as R approaches infinity) growth rate in plane Poiseuille flow is approximately 0·15h/U0, where h is the half-channel width and U0 is the centreline velocity.It is possible to make some progress identifying experimental features of transitional spot structure with aspects of the nonlinear two-dimensional/linear three-dimensional instability. The principal excitation of the eigenfunction of the three-dimensional (growing) disturbance is localized within a given periodicity length (in both the stream and cross-stream directions) near the vorticity maxima of the two-dimensional flow; its planwise structure corresponds to that of observed streaks in early transitional spots; its vortical structure resembles that of a streamwise vortex lifting off the wall. As the three-dimensional disturbance grows to finite amplitude, the flows become chaotic with statistical structure similar to that observed experimentally in moderate-Reynolds-number turbulent shear flows.